Further Information

The Osteen decision on the EPA's ETS scam | US Federal District Court
Article Published: 1998/07/17

Type: Legal
Published By: US Federal District Court

Further Information

Text of the decision by the US Federal Court on the EPA scam on passive smoking. With extreme contempt and after careful examination, Judge Osteen orders the EPA to vacate its classification of ETS as a carcinogen because based on fraudulent methodology and utter junk science.

But not even the power of a Federal Court can stop the Fraud of the Century. The Osteen decision will be vacated by the Appeals Court technical grounds of jurisdiction — although after the clear statement that Osteen's scientific reasons are not questioned.

Already bent by the Master Settlement Agreement, the tobacco industry did not push the case to the Supreme Court, where it could easily have prevailed. In the meantime judge Osteen was slandered and publicly lynched as a tobacco industry "friend". That was never true — and a burning previous judgement against the industry by the same judge demonstrates it.

That, of course, does not matter for antitobacco fanaticism, as the message is clear: on the grounds that not even one death or disease can be scientifically demonstrated to be caused by active or passive smoking, the judicial system, scientists and any force denouncing public health frauds must be silenced.

The PDF document we present, the best such available, is of relatively poor quality; click here to see the decision in html format.

FORCES is supported solely by the efforts of the readers. Please become a member or donate what you can.

Contact Info
Forces Contacts
Media Contacts
Evidence Categories
Quick Look-Up
List of Methodological Errors in ETS Studies
Hill's Criteria and Authoritative Citations
What Must an Epidemiologic Study Warrant?
Table of All Studies on ETS and Lung Cancer up to 2006

Pie Charts of ETS/Lung Cancer Studies
How many cigarettes must be smoked to create an ETS danger?

Passive Smoking: an Institutional Problem
A 13-minute video to understand the fraud

If you like to read rather then listen, download
Now available for free